Christians Have Questions

We are a community who believe that's a good thing. What's your question?
Posted By What the God
http://whatthegod.blogspot.com/2010/04/umtongues.html

What's the deal with tongues? In this article, Jesse Medina recounts his experience in an Assemblies of God church with a high value on speaking in tongues. But what about the weirdness? Can we throw tongues out altogether? Read and Interact

Posted By Anonymous on/at 10:27 PM

Written by Jesse Medina

Half way through my freshman year of high school I moved from a podunk town in Utah to Oregon. At this time, I was not a Christian, though I believed I was simply because I believed in God. However, I began attending an Assemblies of God (A/G) church with my mother and was eventually saved…I think…after responding to a few altar calls.

At one point, my friend Nick from Utah came to visit me in Oregon. Nick grew up Catholic. So when he came to church with us at our charismatic, the-more-crazy-stuff-that-happens-the-more-the-Holy-Spirit-is-moving church, it was an interesting experience. Luckily for him, that day the Spirit was tired and there wasn’t much crazy.

But that would never stop some people from passionately and suddenly raising their hands whilst singing a particularly good chorus. And when they did, Nick did a sort of duck, like he thought someone was about to smack him, and then looked at me with his face half-twisted and mouthed something to the extent of, “What the f*%k?”

I just laughed. Really, though, I was secretly embarrassed. I loved lifting my hands in worship. But I didn’t want Nick to think less of me so I didn’t that day.

Nick went home a few days later, but I stayed at that church for several years. In fact, it was at that church that I learned all kinds of stuff, was mentored, sensed God’s call for me to be a pastor, and yes…was baptized in the Holy Spirit. How do I know? Well, for the A/G folks, when you’re baptized by the Holy Spirit, you speak in what is called “tongues.” Now for us, it was a very meaningful, deep experience. But for those outside of the charismatic circles, and I’m sure for Nick (if he were there), it would mean we had lost our freakin’ minds and were possessed with some kind of demon who had a speaking dysfunction.

From what I was taught, there are two types of tongues: the kind where you speak other languages without having learned that language (like Japanese or Spanish), and the kind where you have a sort of “prayer language” and communicate with God through un-understandable sounds. For the record, I’ve never personally known anyone who had the first type, but I’ve heard they are out there.

But for the A/G folks, they thought everyone should have the second type. And if you didn’t, you hadn’t been baptized in the Holy Spirit and thus had a sort of inferior spirituality. I’m not sure that anyone would actually be willing to say that to your face, and believe me, I tried to get some people to admit it at a later point when I started questioning some of this stuff, but I can’t help but feel that’s what it boils down to.

But, I don’t know that we can throw tongues out altogether.

What if it is true that through some sort of un-understandable moans and groans and otherwise nonsense, we are actually praying in a deeper way? Or even letting the Spirit pray through us?

Is it beyond the realm of possibility?

I don’t think so. Still, though, its weird. And I can’t help but feel that, if you’re not from that tradition, if that is foreign to you like it was to my friend Nick, that is going to really freak you out. I mean, be honest, doesn’t it seem like that’s what cults do? Speak in tongues, play Magic the Gathering, and drink kool-aid?

I’m not sure what I think. What do you think? How have you processed through tongues?

Oh, and for those of you who have no clue what I’m talking about…if you’ve never heard someone speak in tongues, just say the following a few times fast and people will think that the Holy Spirit has got a hold of you.

Bought a Mazda, shoulda bought a Honda.

Posted in
Comments (6)

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I can sum up my thoughts pretty simply: Speaking in tongues is a gift that some are blessed to have and be able to use, but the Bible is clear that not everyone is going to do it (1 Cor 12:7-11). It never sat well with me when my AG profs in theology classes would talk about it like it was something you HAVE to do if you have a genuine relationship with God.
I was raised United Methodist, did a short stint in the Free Methodist, and then a longer stint in the Assembly of God and am now non-denominational ....and have shaken out to agree with Corrigan. It IS indeed a gift that is given today, but not all will have that gift and I hate that the AG's push a doctrine that uses one gift as the evidence of someone being filled with the Spirit when many other gifts are listed as evidence. I don't think that their understanding is scripturally accurate by any means, even though I subscribed to it for a few years during my teens. =) BTW...nice blog. =)
While I believe in the gift of tongues (it's in the Bible after all) the charismatic interpretation of it is off base.

In 1 Corinthians 14 the apostle Paul goes into great detail about the gift of tongues and in verse 28 specifically states "If there is no interpreter, the speaker should keep quiet in the church and speak to himself and God".

Sorry to "bible thump" this topic, but the answer seems kind of black & white.
I agree and def. disagree with all the comments and the blog post...I was raised AJ but my parents moved us from one denomination to another time and time again...from Nazarene to free-will Baptist- four square, and Non-denominational...and I must say I can see where people would feel you had to speak in tongues to be filled with the Holy spirit but I think that's ONE church or ONE pastor b/c spending most my influential yrs in AG and going to camp and blah blah blah I never felt pressured unless it was by ONE pastor that felt that way or ONE church that felt that way.
On the OTHER SIDE...I think tongues are AMAZING! it's like nothing people can explain and YES YES YES there are other ways to feel Jesus and His presence but to actually experience what they received in Acts and to hear someone speaking in tongues behind you while you're being prayed for is supernatural! It's Jesus and that's ALL no words can express!! And I would hate for people to knock it just b/c it never happened to them or just b/c it was different...B/C treating things badly b/c they're different is WRONG and instead we should think of them in LOVE and sing this song..."I can be your friend...lalala" GET it though?!
**Don't knock it till you try it (especially something Jesus wants and has for His people)**

P.S. I do agree with KC on the out-loud grabbing the mic in church tongues though I've seen it done according to His word and then not...so be careful!

Post a new comment

Comments by